Skip to content


We are so blessed at HLS to have such a wonderful collection of teachers with a wide range of educational backgrounds and many years of personal and professional experience in a number of careers.  Most of all, we appreciate the character and commitment they each hold to model excellence in both academics and Christ like conduct.  Each of them possess an interest and love for the subjects they teach and a desire to help your students grow and develop in their academic abilities.


Judie Huston


M.A., Counseling Psychology, Trinity Divinity School

B.A., Communications/Writing, Moody Bible Institute


Jennifer Wiley

Director of Admissions and Records

B.S. Elementary Education, Taylor University


Cindy Davis

Upper School Director Physical Science, Geometry, Algebra I | College Counseling

M.S. Mechanical Engineering, Purdue University

B.S. Mechanical Engineering, University of Illinois
Sheri Marshall

Lower School Director

B.S. Elementary Education, Ball State University


Susan Wible Director of Finance & Accounting

Pre-Algebra, Algebra I

B.S. Accounting, Oral Roberts University


Michelle Vackar

Office Manager | Junior Kindergarten Teacher

B.S. Advertising and Public Relations | Double Minor in Art and Business, Ball State University


Laurie Hibbitt

Upper School Administrative Assistant Latin, Logic, Rhetoric


Dottie Branson

Lower School Administrative Assistant


Lower School Faculty Kindergarten- 6th Grade

Kimberley Winkle


M.A. in Public Administration from Indiana University

B.A. in Elementary Education from DePauw University


Karen Cavanagh

First Grade


Kathy Greenslade

First Grade

B.S. Elementary Education, Saint Mary of the Woods College


Melissa Achenbach

Second Grade

B.S. Elementary Education, Ball State University


Nancy Miller

Third Grade

B.S. Elementary Education, Indiana University


Dawn Brown Fourth Grade

B.A. Elementary Education, North Central University


Marilynn Stubbs

Fifth Grade

B.S. Special Education | Minor in Music Therapy and Flute Performance, Ball State University

Certified Dyslexia Therapy, Orton-Gilingham


Loretta Thompson

Fifth Grade

B.A. Liberal Arts, University of Indianapolis


Brittany Garrison

Sixth Grade

M.A. School Administration, Indiana Wesleyan University

B.S. Elementary Education and Special Needs, Indiana Wesleyan University


Upper School Faculty 7th Grade – 12th Grade

Vince Cutrona Classical Studies, Greek, Latin,

M.A. Gordon Conwell Theological Seminary

B.A. History and Greek, Calvin College


Donna Grace Dickmeyer

Biology I, Chemistry, Anatomy/Physiology, Math 7 B.S. Biochemistry, Wheaton College


Andrew Garrison

Classical Studies, Earth Science, Geography,

B.A. Biblical History, Indiana Wesleyan University

B.S. Social Studies Education, Indiana Wesleyan University


Justin Kauffman

Greek, Latin

M.A. Old Testament, Gordon Conwell Theological Seminary

M.A. Biblical Languages, Gordon Conwell Theological Seminary

B.A. Bible and Religion, Anderson University


Andrea Reinhard

English Studies

B.A. Secondary English Education, Anderson University


Brooke Riddell

English Studies M.F.A. Creative Writing, Indiana University

B.A. English Composition/American Literature, DePauw University 2015 Classical Teaching Apprenticeship with CiRCE Institute


Holly Rohrbach

Algebra I, Pre-Calculus, Calculus,

M.S. in Computer Engineering from the University of Central Florida

B.S. in Electrical Engineering from Colorado State University


Physical Education, Art, and Music

Amy Fata

Music (Grades 3-12)

M.S. Vocal Performance, Butler University

B.A. Choral Music Education, Huntington University


Abigail Smith

Music (Grades K-2), Handbells Choir

B.A. Music, Piano Performance, Butler University


Lori Schloemer

Art (K-6th) | P.E. (K-4th)

B.A. Fine Arts, Iowa State